Thursday, October 21, 2010

So Who's Really Number One?



Traditional college football powers Alabama and Ohio State have gone down in flames in recent weeks, and the latest polls have Oregon sitting in the top spot.

But then, when the first BCS rankings — which will determine, eventually, the two schools that will play for the national title in January — came out, as they always do in midseason, Oklahoma was sitting in the top spot.

So, according to the BCS, if the season ended today, Oklahoma would be in the title game. Oregon would still be in it — but as the #2 team.

And Boise State, currently ranked second in the old–fashioned polls conducted by and with humans, is left out of the title game by the computer.

No wonder Steve Wieberg and Jack Carey write in USA Today that the BCS could be headed for a big mess at the end of the season.

Darren Everson observes in the Wall Street Journal that Oregon's ascendance is a clear sign that college football's "middle class" is on the rise.

And that may be so. But, with Boise State and TCU angling to get into the Big Game, the NCAA's bottom–feeding conferences are making their bids for "Hoosiers"–like immortality. That may seem very democratic to some people, but there really is nothing democratic about sports contests, is there?

Both teams are given an equal opportunity to compete, of course, But, if you asked for a show of hands at tonight's UCLA–Oregon game on the question of whether Oregon or Oklahoma should be #1, I'd bet dollars to doughnuts that the vast majority would vote for Oregon.

But if you asked that same question at the next Oklahoma home game, you'd get a much different response.

Sports contests are not about persuasion, and that is what is going to be needed for college football to get a legitimate national championship game. To persuade the powers that be that the current system is a sham and an injustice, it is going to take some situations where at least one truly deserving team was clearly left out in the cold — perhaps two.

It remains to be seen if that will happen this year.

Of course, nothing is going to be settled this week. In fact, it is possible that the team that is currently atop the human polls could lose — for the third consecutive week.

Fasten your seatbelts. The second half of the season could be a bumpy ride.

Two teams are idle this week: Second–ranked Boise State and #16 Florida State. All times are Central.

Today
  • UCLA at #1 Oregon, 8 p.m. on ESPN: Oregon is 7–2 in its last nine games with UCLA, but before 2000, Oregon rarely beat UCLA.

    For that matter, I believe this will be the first time that Oregon's football team takes the field as the top–ranked team in the country. And John Canzano of The Oregonian hopes the Ducks make it to the title game so Oregon's coach, who is earning a reputation for bluntness, will be in a position to tell off the BCS.

    But, at this point, it is anyone's guess who will be in the national championship game. If the current rankings are to be believed, it will be Oregon and Boise State. But Oklahoma will have something to say about that, as will the winner of this week's LSU–Auburn game.

    Will one of those schools — or someone else, a once–beaten Alabama, say, or Michigan State or the winner of the Wisconsin–Iowa game — leap past the top two? Time will tell.

    Or will Oregon run the table? That's a dicey proposition in the Pac–10. I guess it all starts with this game.

    Offense always seems to be decisive in the Pac–10, and not only does Oregon have the top–rated offense in the conference, but the Ducks also have the top–rated offense in the nation. UCLA is 99th.

    Chris Dufresne writes in the Los Angeles Times that Oregon's quickness is killing its foes. It's hard to argue that point.

    Defense is the redheaded stepchild in the Pac–10. Oregon is ranked higher than UCLA in defense, but that really means little. Oregon's defense is 38th in the nation; UCLA's is 65th.

    I'll take Oregon and its offense.
Saturday
  • #3 Oklahoma at #18 Missouri, 7 p.m. on ABC: The last time these schools met was in the Big 12 championship game in December 2008. OU cruised to a 62–21 victory.

    The year before that, OU beat Mizzou twice — during the regular season (41–31) and in the Big 12 title game (38–17). In 2006, OU beat Missouri in Columbia.

    The teams play in different divisions so they don't face each other every year, like they did in the days of the old Big Eight Conference, but Missouri's last win over Oklahoma came in 1998. And that is Missouri's only win over OU in more than 25 years.

    I don't think the numbers particularly work in Missouri's favor, either. OU has the higher–rated offense (17th to 43rd), but Missouri has the higher–rated defense (29th to 71st).

    While we're on the subject of defense ...

    It's worth remembering that Missouri hasn't faced a Top 25 foe yet, while OU has played (and beaten) two teams that are currently ranked and a third team that was ranked earlier this season. There's a big difference between giving up 20 points to Texas and giving up 24 points to San Diego State.

    I'll take Oklahoma.

  • Air Force at #4 TCU, 7 p.m. on CBSCSN: As conference rivals, TCU has won four of five encounters with Air Force.

    Both teams have Top 15 offenses (Air Force is 13th, TCU is 15th). But TCU has a clear edge on defense. The Frogs are second in the nation while Air Force is 42nd.

    I'll pick TCU to bottle up Air Force's best–in–the–nation ground attack and win the game.

  • #6 LSU at #5 Auburn, 2:30 p.m. on CBS: This is the game of the week — hands down.

    And, while you probably don't need any additional hype piled onto this one, MSNBC says this is one of the 12 biggest games left in the regular season.

    Ya think?

    For several years (between 2000 and 2007), the home team won this game.

    Lately, the advantage has belonged to LSU, winner of the last three. But this year, LSU has been enjoying an increasingly unlikely streak of improbable victories. It's a house of cards, and it's been apt to come tumbling down for several weeks now.

    Auburn, meanwhile, has just been downright convincing in its triumphs.

    Whether LSU can make it four in a row remains to be seen. But five of the last six meetings have been decided by a touchdown or less. And the current rankings would suggest another down–to–the–wire finish.

    The battle may well be decided when Auburn has the ball. That should be the marquee matchup. Auburn's offense is ninth in the nation while LSU's defense is third.

    You might want to go to the bathroom and visit the kitchen for something to eat or drink when LSU has the ball. LSU's offense shouldn't be too fearful. It is ranked 92nd in the nation, one spot ahead of Louisiana–Monroe. Auburn's defense is in the middle of the pack, ranked 63rd.

    I think I'll pick Auburn in what may be considered a mild upset.

  • #7 Alabama at Tennessee, 6 p.m. on ESPN: Both schools have known success against the other. Tennessee is 10–5 against Alabama since 1995. Alabama had a similar advantage from 1980 to 1994 (10–4–1).

    Neither is intimidated by the other. Last year, when Alabama went unbeaten and won the national title, Tennessee came closer to knocking off the Crimson Tide than any other school.

    But Alabama enters this game with decisive advantages in both offense and defense. I pick Alabama.

  • #8 Michigan State at Northwestern, 11 a.m. on ESPN: Since 1997, Michigan State holds a narrow 6–5 advantage over the Wildcats, and the Spartans are 3–2 at Northwestern.

    Northwestern is better than you might have thought, but Michigan State is ranked higher in both categories (23rd to 33rd in each). I pick Michigan State to win its third straight against Northwestern.

  • Colorado State at #9 Utah, 5 p.m. on The Mtn.: Utah has won four in a row over Colorado State.

    As long as Utah's defense (seventh in the nation) can control Colorado State's 83rd–ranked offense, I have every reason to believe the Utes' 27th–ranked offense can get by CSU's 94th–ranked defense.

    There's no reason to think this one will be close. Utah should win its fifth straight against Colorado State.

  • #10 Wisconsin at #13 Iowa, 2:30 p.m. on ABC: This series ebbs and flows, and right now it looks pretty even.

    Adam Rittenberg of ESPN.com says they are reflections of each other.

    That frequently seems to be the case. And often, as George Wallace (the Southern segregationist politician, that is) used to say, there isn't a dime's worth of difference between the two.

    Since 1995, Iowa holds a slim 8–7 advantage. Often, one team will win four or five games in a row, then the other will start a comparable streak. Lately, teams have been winning in twos. If that trend continues, that would mean it is Wisconsin's turn.

    Defense may hold the key this time; both schools are in the nation's Top 25 on defense (Iowa is 13th, Wisconsin is 23rd).

    I don't mean to suggest that the offensive rankings are terrible. They just aren't as gaudy. Wisconsin is 28th in the nation, Iowa is 39th.

    I'll go with the home team, Iowa. and its defense against a Wisconsin team that may be a little too prone to be overconfident after beating Ohio State.

  • Purdue at #11 Ohio State, 11 a.m. on the Big Ten Network: Ohio State has dominated Purdue, 18–5, since 1981. But last year, a struggling Purdue team handed Ohio State its second loss — and its last, until the Buckeyes went to Wisconsin last weekend.

    The 2009 Purdue team had lost five in a row prior to its date with Ohio State. This edition is 4–2 and currently unbeaten in Big Ten play.

    Ohio State enjoys the advantage on both sides of the ball. The Buckeyes's offense (25th in the nation) might struggle against the Boilermakers' #41 defense, but it seems to me that Purdue's offense (72nd in the nation) is likely to have much more difficulty moving the ball against Ohio State's sixth–ranked defense.

    I'll take Ohio State.

  • Washington State at #12 Stanford, 4 p.m. on FCS: Stanford has a 9–6 advantage over Washington State since 1995.

    Offense rules in the Pac–10, and Stanford's offense is ranked 12th in the nation (WSU's is 86th). Defense is often an afterthought in the Pac–10, but Stanford has the edge there, too, holding a #56 ranking while Washington State is 120th.

    Stanford is an easy pick.

  • #14 Nebraska at #17 Oklahoma State, 2:30 p.m. on ABC: Oklahoma State has quietly compiled a 6–0 record while Nebraska was 5–0 before losing to Texas last week.

    As non–divisional rivals, these schools haven't faced each other every year since the demise of the Big Eight. In fact, this will be their first meeting since 2007. And now, with Nebraska leaving for the Big Ten after this season, who knows when they will face each other again?

    OSU fans might not be too eager to resume the series. Although the Cowboys have had the upper hand in recent years, between 1962 and 2002, the schools met nearly every year and Nebraska won every time (except 1973, when the schools played to a tie). And Nebraska has been returning to national prominence since the last time these schools faced each other.

    Both teams are in the Top 25 in total offense — Oklahoma State is second and Nebraska is 24th. But Nebraska has the edge on defense, and it is more decisive (the Cornhuskers are ninth in the nation, the Cowboys are 92nd).

    Defense favors Nebraska.

  • Washington at #15 Arizona, 9:15 p.m. on ESPN: This has been a pretty competitive series. In the last 20 meetings, Washington has won 12 times.

    But the numbers really seem to favor Arizona this time, especially if the game turns into a defensive struggle. Arizona is 10th in the nation in defense while Washington is 98th.

    Arizona also has the guns to win a shootout, with an offense that is 30th (Washington is 46th).

    I pick Arizona.

  • #19 South Carolina at Vanderbilt, 6 p.m. on FSS: Since 2000, South Carolina is 8–2 against Vanderbilt.

    The bad news for South Carolina is that Vandy's wins came in 2007 and 2008.

    South Carolina outranks Vanderbilt in both offense and defense. The rankings aren't gaudy in either category, but I'm inclined to think that South Carolina's offense, which is far superior to Vanderbilt's, will make the difference.

    I pick South Carolina.

  • Syracuse at #20 West Virginia, 11 a.m. on ESPN2: West Virginia has beaten Syracuse eight straight times. Syracuse's last win at West Virginia was in 2000.

    This game has the makings of a defensive struggle. Both teams are in the Top 20 in defense — West Virginia is fifth in the nation, Syracuse is 18th. The offenses, on the other hand, are atrocious. West Virginia is 64th, Syracuse is 73rd.

    I look for a low–scoring struggle, with West Virginia eventually claiming the victory.


  • Ole Miss at #21 Arkansas, 11:21 a.m. on SEC Network: Former Arkansas coach Houston Nutt will be making his second trip to Fayetteville since leaving to become coach at Ole Miss. He's 2–0 against his old team.

    They always seem to have a lot of fun at Nutt's expense in my home state, but in the recent history of this series, Nutt seems to be the difference between winning and losing. During his tenure at Arkansas, he was 7–3 against Ole Miss.

    But I think the numbers are against him this time. Arkansas is 10th in the nation on offense, while Ole Miss is 54th.

    Defense doesn't appear to be either team's strongest point. Arkansas is 32nd in the nation, and Ole Miss is 52nd.

    I think Arkansas will win this time.

  • Iowa State at #22 Texas, 11 a.m. on FSN: Until they became members of the same conference in the mid–1990s, Texas and Iowa State hadn't faced each other since 1979.

    As members of different divisions, they don't play each other every year. But, otherwise, not a whole lot has changed. Texas won that game in '79 — and has won all six meetings with the Cyclones since become a member of the Big 12.

    I expect Texas to win again.

  • Duke at #23 Virginia Tech, 11 a.m. on ACC Network: Virginia Tech is 6–0 against Duke since joining the ACC in 2004.

    And I know that Virginia Tech dropped a stunner to James Madison earlier this season.

    But, come on, this is Duke. I know Tech has a minimal edge on offense (Tech is 42nd, Duke is 51st). But the Seminoles have a much greater edge on offense (Tech is 51st, Duke is 101st).

    And, as nearly as I can tell, Duke hasn't won a football game at Virginia Tech in more than half a century.

    Don't hold your breath waiting for Duke to win this Saturday. I pick Virginia Tech.

  • UAB at #24 Mississippi State, 6 p.m. on ESPNU: Well, as I said earlier in the season, I expected Mississippi State to rise up and upset someone — I just never thought it would be against Florida.

    So is Mississippi State actually a good team? Or is Florida — now skidding along on a three–game losing streak — something that hasn't happened to the Gators since losing to Florida State, Alabama and Michigan State between November 1999 and January 2000 — just a really bad football team?

    To give you an idea of how rare something like this is in Gatorland, two of those losses were in the postseason. The last time the Gators lost three in a row during the regular season, Ronald Reagan was still president.

    Well, anyway, now Mississippi State has compiled a respectable 5–2 record — and those two losses were against LSU and Auburn, who are headed for a major showdown this weekend. It kinda looks like MSU might be for real.

    This will be the fourth time these teams have met since 2004. UAB caught MSU in a down year in 2004 and won the game, but MSU has won the last two contests. I'm inclined to think that Mississippi State, which has won four in a row, will make it five.

  • North Carolina at #25 Miami (Florida), 6:30 p.m. on ESPN2: Believe it or not, North Carolina is 4–2 against Miami since they became conference rivals in 2004.

    And North Carolina has won the last three in a row.

    If the game is decided on defense — and I think it might be — I give the edge to Miami, which is 21st in the nation in defense (North Carolina is 33rd). Neither team has been anything special on offense — Miami is 56th, North Carolina is 63rd.

    Give me Miami.
Last week: 13–8

Season: 118–23

Friday, October 15, 2010

Rangers Take National Stage

Tonight is a remarkable night in the history of baseball in north Texas.

Tonight, a league championship series begins in Arlington for the first time ever. I know there were many — myself included — who thought this day would never come.

And I have been to a Rangers game that was played in what was probably as close to a World Series atmosphere as anything anyone in these parts could imagine.

In late April 1989, a co–worker and I got tickets and went to Arlington to see the Rangers play the Boston Red Sox. Nolan Ryan had just signed with the Rangers, and we had calculated, based on the pitching rotations, when Ryan and Roger Clemens were likely to face each other, and we got tickets about 10 days ahead of time.

It was a gamble, of course. Either team could have been rained out once or twice, and that could have altered their pitching rotations. But nothing like that happened, and Ryan and Clemens faced off on a warm, sunny Sunday afternoon before what seemed to be a capacity crowd.

The game was a pitchers' duel. As I recall, the Red Sox took a 2–1 lead early in the game, and it remained that way until the bottom of the ninth, when Rafael Palmeiro belted a two–run homer, and the Rangers won, 3–2.

Ryan, who was 42 at the time, pitched into the eighth. I didn't find out until I was in the car on my way home that he had been having back spasms since the second inning. But he kept pitching — and kept shutting out the Red Sox — until the Rangers could scratch out the runs they needed to take the lead.

The 2010 Rangers may need that kind of endurance. They had to go the distance in a best–of–five series with Tampa just to get this far, and, fittingly, the team that has won more World Series than any other, the New York Yankees, stands between the Rangers and their debut in the Fall Classic.

Many of my friends in these parts are adjusting their schedules so they can watch the Rangers in the World Series. A couple of days ago, I heard on a local radio station that folks were already camping out at the Ballpark so they can be assured of getting World Series tickets when they go on sale on Sunday. I hope they can get a refund if the Yankees turn out to be the American League's representatives.

Because one thing is for sure — nothing will be certain about the World Series by this Sunday. Yet there are people who will sleep in pup tents and sleeping bags outside a ballpark for four or five nights just to get tickets for what may be a once–in–a–lifetime event.

That's a tribute to Ryan, who is part–owner and team president now. His journey in baseball has seemed, at times, wildly improbable.

Early in his career, he was a relief pitcher for the Amazin' Mets of 1969. Many observers may have written him off in the 1970s, when he labored for a mostly weak California Angels franchise, but he wound up taking them to the playoffs in his final season with them and putting them on the road to continued baseball success. After that, he returned to his native state and played for the Houston Astros for most of the 1980s, helping them to their first playoff series. He concluded his playing career with five seasons in Texas.

There is great anticipation here — where baseball may belatedly join the other major team sports (football, basketball, hockey) that have played for championships. In a sense, the Rangers already have joined that group (or, at least, they will when the first pitch is thrown in Arlington tonight) in this series that will decide the AL champion.

But I speak of overall championships, and, in baseball, those are only won in the World Series. The Rangers must get past the Yankees before they can play Philadelphia or San Francisco for all the marbles.

In a year when the Cowboys, Stars and Mavericks have all been disappointments locally, the Rangers have been bringing back some of that Texas swagger.

"Bring on the Evil Empire," writes Jeff Wilson in the Fort Worth Star–Telegram.

Well, I hope folks enjoy it while they can because I think that expecting to deprive the Yankees of a World Series appearance in the same year that George Steinbrenner died is asking a bit much of the baseball gods.

The Rangers have been playing ball here in north Texas for nearly 40 years. Who knows when they will see fit to send another league championship series this way?

Thursday, October 14, 2010

Will Another #1 Go Down This Week?

Football dynasties sure ain't what they used to be.

Ivan Maisel of ESPN.com observes that "[t]he shelf life of a dynasty used to be about the same as a good cabernet — somewhere between 10 and 15 years." Now, though, it "may be closer to a presidential term."

And he makes some good points about how everything has accelerated. Clearly, today's faster pace has changed every life — some for the better, some not — and it has brought changes to college football that were unexpected even a few years ago.

Recently, Stewart Mandel of Sports Illustrated wrote of the SEC's "new reality."

And, indeed, positioned within Mandel's parameters, he seems to raise a good point.

In the aftermath of Alabama's first defeat since January 2009, Mandel says it is entirely possible that a one–loss SEC team might play for the national title — but should it?

As an Arkansas graduate, I find it gratifying that Mandel now calls 'Bama's win against Arkansas a few weeks ago the Crimson Tide's "signature victory" — until I realize that it is largely by default. Alabama's early win over Penn State, Mandel observes, meant a lot at the time but means very little now, since subsequent games have shown that Penn State's offense is the Big Ten's worst.

And, likewise, Alabama's win over Florida only two weeks ago doesn't mean much since the Gators' last–minute loss to LSU last weekend.

But, it seems to me, that is how it always is in the SEC. The conference is so deep that, truly, on any given Saturday, any SEC school can beat any other SEC school, regardless of reputations, rankings or records. Teams that looked weak in their last game may look invincible in their next. It's the toughest conference in college football.

In the larger context, I think Maisel is on to the more significant development — the reduced shelf lives of dynasties in general.

When Mandel talks about the toppling of Alabama as the "new reality," he conveniently overlooks the SEC's competitive history since the end of the Bear Bryant era nearly 30 years ago. Since that time, Auburn, Georgia, LSU, Florida and Tennessee have all enjoyed periods in the spotlight; even Ole Miss and SEC newcomer Arkansas have risen to greater prominence.

Now it is South Carolina's turn.

Yet the SEC was competitive even in the Bear's day. For all the national titles the Bear won, there were more seasons when one team would rise up and knock off Goliath. Frequently, it was seen as lightning in a bottle — a case of one extremely gifted player (i.e., Archie Manning) leading his team to an improbable upset of the great Bear Bryant or capturing the public's attention in years when his school had the good fortune not to have to face Alabama (i.e., Herschel Walker).

Recent discussions in the blogosphere suggest that the SEC will be out of the national title picture now that Alabama has been beaten, and that may be so.

But it's worth remembering that South Carolina was ranked 19th when it beat Alabama. The Gamecocks did not come from nowhere. This is the SEC being the SEC.

And Alabama, as it so often had to do in the Bear's day, must rebound from a single defeat and accept that its fate is no longer in its hands.

We're only about halfway through college football's regular season. A lot can happen — and, by December, a one–loss SEC team might look pretty darn good to the BCS.

If the caliber of the competition can no longer do it, I guess that will have to motivate the Crimson Tide now.

Two ranked teams are idle this week: #2 Oregon and #14 Stanford. All times are Central.

Today
  • South Florida at #25 West Virginia, 6:30 p.m. on ESPN: These two schools have been in the same conference since 2005.

    And I'll bet you didn't know that South Florida is 3–2 against West Virginia since that time.

    South Florida has built its advantage with a 2–1 record at home. But the teams are tied, 1–1, at West Virginia — and the Mountaineers won the last time they hosted the Bulls.

    At 3–2, the Bulls aren't bad. One of their losses was a rather sound thrashing at the hands of #22 Florida. But West Virginia's only loss so far was a somewhat narrow to defeat to #9 LSU — and LSU just beat Florida last weekend.

    It is seldom useful, actually, to compare scores in that way. But, at this stage of the season, it can provide a helpful context in which to assess this game. And my assesment is that West Virginia will win.
Saturday
  • #1 Ohio State at #18 Wisconsin, 6 p.m. on ESPN: I don't know when Ohio State was last ranked #1. The Buckeyes won a national title more than seven years ago in an overtime battle with Miami (Florida).

    Dennis Dodd of CBS Sports makes a legitimate observation. When the top–ranked team falls, the polls elevate the next in line.

    Even when the next in line hasn't been as impressive as, say, #3 or #4 or #5. And Dodd insists that the Buckeyes haven't been that impressive.

    "Boise State has beaten more ranked teams," Dodd writes. "Oregon has been more impressive. TCU has posted consecutive shutouts. Utah just laid 68 on Iowa State.

    "Free thinking has never been the polls' strong point."


    Quite true, but the Buckeyes still have a few hurdles to clear before they can play for another national title. And one of them is this Saturday in Madison, Wisc.

    The 5–1 Badgers won't play at home again for a month so they would surely like to leave Wisconsin with a win over the top–ranked team in the land. But that will be much easier said than done.

    Ohio State holds a tenuous 5–4 edge over Wisconsin in their sporadic series since 1999. And nearly half of those games were decided by a touchdown or less.

    It is, to be sure, a far cry from the days of the legendary Woody Hayes, who tied Wisconsin more frequently than he lost to the Badgers in nearly three decades of roaming the sidelines at Ohio State.

    But the Buckeyes have won their last three games with Wisconsin so recent history is on their side. And, in a game in which both teams have Top 25 offenses and defenses, you have to look for whatever edge you can find.

    In this case, Ohio State enjoys a statistical edge in both categories, but it seems to me that Wisconsin's schedule has been a little tougher. The Buckeyes' most significant opponent to date is the now–unranked Miami Hurricanes. Wisconsin's only loss came two weeks ago against #13 Michigan State.

    It's probably an upset special — a clear case of lightning striking twice in just about the same place in consecutive weeks — but I'm going to predict a Wisconsin victory.

  • #3 Boise State at San Jose State, 7 p.m. on ESPN3.com: Boise State is 9–0 against San Jose State since the teams became conference rivals in 2001.

    Sometimes the scores have been close, sometimes they haven't. The point is, though, that Boise State has San Jose State's number.

    I have no problem picking Boise State to win this one.

  • Brigham Young at #4 TCU, 3 p.m. on Versus: TCU leads this series, 3–2, since the teams became Mountain West rivals in 2005. In those five years, the fans have just about seen it all from these two teams.

    Do you like offense? TCU has plenty (11th in the nation), BYU not so much (91st).

    Maybe you're a devotee of defense? TCU has the nation's top–ranked defense while BYU's is 90th.

    And, if that isn't enough, BYU brings a 2–4 record into the game while 6–0 TCU still entertains thoughts of playing for a national title.

    The dream continues. TCU will win.

  • Texas at #5 Nebraska, 2:30 p.m. on ABC/ESPN: This is a rematch of the riveting Big 12 championship game from a year ago — and, barring totally unexpected developments that might pair the teams in another conference title matchup, it may be the teams' last meeting for awhile.

    And John Tamanaha of NBC Sports says it will be one of the most crucial games in resolving the "BCS mess" left by Alabama's loss last week to South Carolina.

    "Just when you think the Longhorns are short of what it takes to be a factor in the national picture," he writes, "they could jump up and let everyone know that they're still around."

    The teams seem to be headed in opposite directions, and I guess some 'Husker fans have been a little cocky, but Cindy Lange–Kubick of the Lincoln Journal Star has already served notice: " I hope I don't have to hear one more person say anything close to this: Texas isn't such a big game anymore ..."

    Perhaps she is right when she says such talk merely invites the gods of sports "to stab you in the back with a Texas–sized victory."

    Brian Christopherson writes that the Nebraska offensive line will face its greatest test yet when it lines up against Texas, which may be an understatement. Texas' defense is sixth in the nation (Nebraska's is 12th).

    But that O–line has helped Nebraska climb to seventh in the nation in total offense so I'm inclined to agree with Christopherson when he suggests it will be the key to the game. If the Nebraska offense can handle the Texas defense — and I think it will — Nebraska's defense should have little difficulty containing Texas' offense, which is ranked 71st in the nation.

    As long as they don't get overconfident, I pick the Nebraska Cornhuskers.

  • Iowa State at #6 Oklahoma, 6 p.m. on FSN: In the days of the old Big Eight conference, these schools met every season in football. Since the members merged with half of the old Southwest Conference, they have belonged to different divisions — and, thus, now meet occasionally.

    Otherwise, though, not much has changed, really.

    Since the Big 12 opened for business in 1996, Oklahoma is 6–0 against Iowa State. Between 1980 and 1995, when the teams played every year in the Big Eight, OU won every encounter but two — a loss in 1990 and a tie in 1981.

    Both of those exceptions, ironically, occurred in Norman.

    Well, I don't think this game will be an exception. I expect Oklahoma to win.

  • #12 Arkansas at #7 Auburn, 2:30 p.m. on CBS: The first time these schools faced each other as conference opponents, in 1992, it ended in a tie, 24–24.

    The next 17 games were practically a split decision, with Auburn winning nine and Arkansas winning eight. And the numbers from the current season suggest a close contest — in keeping with tight nature of the series.

    Arkansas' only blemish was to defending national champion Alabama last month. But Auburn is undefeated — and that includes a victory over South Carolina, the team that just beat Alabama.

    Both teams, in fact, are in the Top 20 in total offense. In spite of Arkansas QB Ryan Mallett (seventh in the nation in passing efficiency), who is often mentioned as a Heisman prospect, Auburn actually is ranked ahead of Arkansas in total offense (led by quarterback Cam Newton).

    But the Razorbacks have a sizable edge over the Tigers in total defense — and that may be the Razorbacks' best hope for a victory on the road. The defense, after all, has been facing some productive offenses in its recent outings. It kept the Alabama offense (currently 25th in the nation) under control until the fourth quarter and managed to bottle up Texas A&M's offense (15th in the country) last week.

    Arkansas has won the last two meetings and, obviously, would like to make it three straight. Similarly, the Hogs have won the last two times they have visited Auburn. Auburn's last home victory against Arkansas was in 2004.

    Based on the improved play of Arkansas' defense, I'll take Arkansas to win the game.

  • Ole Miss at #8 Alabama, 8 p.m. on ESPN2: Auburn, LSU and Tennessee get more ink as Alabama's rivals, but, in the SEC, nearly every game has the intensity of a rivalry.

    Especially when the schools are in bordering states, and the campuses are roughly 140 miles apart.

    I'm sure Ole Miss would love to win this game. But I don't think the Rebels will.

    Ole Miss has beaten Alabama twice since 2001 — and the Rebels won only three times in the preceding three decades.

    Plus — as the Rebels are, no doubt, tired of hearing by now — Ole Miss lost to Jacksonville State last month. I just can't see them winning this game on the road.

    I fully expect Alabama to win.

  • McNeese State at #9 LSU, 6 p.m. on ESPN3.com: What, are you kidding me?

    LSU plays SEC teams on a weekly basis. The Tigers have won national titles in recent years.

    Not trying to take anything away from McNeese State. But I'll take LSU to win this one.

    A McNeese victory just seems too improbable in a season in which Jacksonville State and James Madison have already beaten teams from the power conferences.

  • #10 South Carolina at Kentucky, 5 p.m. on ESPN2: The Gamecocks' win over Alabama last Saturday was, indeed, an "afternoon to remember," wrote The State.

    In fact, it wasn't overstating the case to say that it was the "most significant victory" in South Carolina football history.

    But, it seems to me that, unless South Carolina is eager to be a victim of a possibly more significant upset this week, the Gamecocks need to come down from their emotional high. This week's foe is Kentucky — the Wildcats aren't in the Top 25, but they gave seventh–ranked Auburn all it could handle last week. The Gamecocks should take note of that.

    The Wildcats might be hungry for a win at home, especially since Kentucky has lost its last 10 games against South Carolina. It's worth pointing out, though, that, in seven of those games, South Carolina's margin of victory was a touchdown or less.

    And last year, South Carolina only won by two points.

    I expect South Carolina to win, but this one shouldn't be taken lightly.

  • #11 Utah at Wyoming, 5 p.m. on The Mtn.: Utah has dominated this series since 1991, 13–4.

    And there's no real reason to think that will change. I expect Utah to win — and improve its record at Wyoming to 7–3 since 1991.

  • Illinois at #13 Michigan State, 11 a.m. on Big Ten Network: Michigan State's win over Michigan last week meant more than a year's worth of bragging rights. Michael Rosenberg writes in the Detroit Free Press that MSU beating Michigan has become the new normal.

    Maybe he's right. It was, after all, the Spartans' third straight win over their nemesis, and it was their second straight in the Big House after losing in their eight previous trips to Ann Arbor.

    This week's opponent shouldn't pose much of a challenge to the Spartans. Michigan State has beaten Illinois in 10 of their last 11 meetings.

    And, while there are some potential bumps in the road, like a date with Iowa in a couple of weeks and a regular–season finale against currently unranked Penn State (both road games, by the way), Michigan State could well be in the national championship picture when the season comes to its conclusion.

    That assumes, I guess, that the Illini won't win this game. And I don't think they will. I'll take Michigan State.

  • #15 Iowa at Michigan, 2:30 p.m. on ABC: This game could have had a lot of appeal if Michigan had beaten Michigan State last week.

    The Wolverines have won 22 of their last 30 games with the Hawkeyes so winning this game still has a lot of meaning for Iowa. And last year's two–point triumph was meaningful, even though Iowa won 11 games last year and Michigan didn't even break .500.

    But it ended a three–game Michigan winning streak over Iowa — and Hawkeye fans had had plenty of those over the years.

    Still, beating a ranked and unbeaten Michigan team would have had more value for Iowa — and that is precisely what was possible until the Spartans beat the Wolverines. Then Michigan dropped from the rankings.

    The marquee matchup in this game will be between the Michigan offense (ranked third in the nation) against Iowa's defense (ranked fourth in the nation), but the two may offset each other, leaving the game to be decided when Iowa has the ball. And therein lies the problem for Michigan — its defense, which is ranked 112th in the nation. How can it keep pace with Iowa's offense, which is a respectable 33rd in the nation? I don't think it can.

    Give me Iowa.

  • Boston College at #16 Florida State, 11 a.m. on ESPN: Did you know that Boston College has won its last two games with Florida State — and is 3–2 against the Seminoles in the last five years?

    When the defenses are compared, the numbers are quite similar. Florida State's defense is 28th in the nation, Boston College's is 39th.

    But a huge gap exists between the offenses. Florida State's offense, like its defense, is 28th in the nation, but Boston College's offense, at #105, is almost the nation's worst.

    That sounds, to me, as if Boston College will have problems scoring — and scoring points in bunches seems the only way to silence a raucous Florida State crowd.

    I pick Florida State.

  • #17 Arizona at Washington State, 6:30 p.m. on Versus: Arizona has won nearly two–thirds of its games with Washington State in the last 20 years.

    But recent history has shown that the series swings regularly, every three or four years. And I suppose that means it is time for it to swing in WSU's direction.

    Arizona has won the last four meetings, often by wide margins. Before that, Washington State won four straight — usually by closer margins. Arizona won the three games before that.

    Based on that alone, it seems that Washington State is due. But the numbers don't support that. Arizona holds decisive edges in both offense (Arizona is 26th in the nation, Washington State is 85th) and defense (Arizona is 13th, Washington State is 120th).

    I'll take Arizona.

  • #19 Nevada at Hawaii, 10:30 p,m. on ESPN3.com: They've been members of the same conference for the last 10 years, and Hawaii has certainly been a thorn in the Wolf Pack's side, winning six of their 10 confrontations.

    And 4–2 Hawaii definitely poses a threat to 6–0 Nevada — perhaps the only real test until the Boise State game next month. Hawaii, after all, pretty much dominated Fresno State last weekend, and Fresno State was thought to be maybe the only team in the WAC, other than Boise State, that might be good enough to compete on the national stage.

    The numbers so far this season look as close as they can be. Both teams are outstanding on offense — Nevada is ranked second, Hawaii is ranked sixth. Both are mediocre on defense — Nevada is 69th, Hawaii is 72nd.

    So I think the game may be decided by the tone it takes early on. If the score is close, the running game may be favored by both teams — and that would help Nevada, which is fifth in the nation in rushing while Hawaii is 85th in the nation defending the run.

    Hawaii's running game, on the other hand, is one of the nation's worst (ranked 117th) while Nevada is 45th against the run. And my guess is that Hawaii, which runs the ball about 19 times a game and attempts 46 passes per game, is likely to throw the ball regardless of the score.

    And Hawaii, ranked #1 in passing, should be able to pick Nevada apart. The Wolf Pack, who may be battling a case of jet lag, are 82nd in the nation against the pass.

    This may be another upset, but I'll pick Hawaii.

  • #20 Oklahoma State at Texas Tech: As division rivals, these schools have faced each other every year since 1996.

    And, for the last eight years, the home team has been the winner. In fact, only twice has the visiting team won — and, in both cases, Tech was the visiting team.

    Lubbock has been a safe haven for Tech against OSU. As a member of the Big 12, Tech has gone 6–0 at Lubbock against Oklahoma State; as nonconference foes before that, Tech's last home loss to OSU came in 1966.

    But times have changed — and I think Oklahoma State's luck will change. Tech is on the decline. These are not the same Red Raiders who defeated OSU by 36 points in Lubbock two years ago.

  • #21 Missouri at Texas A&M, 11 a.m. on FSN: The schools have split six games since becoming conference foes in 1996 so series history really isn't much of a guide.

    What do the numbers from the current season say? Well, Texas A&M is 15th in the nation in offense whereas Missouri is 43rd. For those of us who grew up in the Southwest Conference, it is remarkable to realize that the Aggies have achieved this with their 11th–ranked passing game — which has been much more productive than the traditional running game.

    What's more, A&M boasts a higher–ranked defense (24th) than Missouri (30th). And the Tigers' pass defense (40th in the nation) appears to be vulnerable.

    The Aggies got off to a strong start against some relatively weak opponents, but the schedule has been increasingly challenging for this A&M team, and it doesn't look much easier with three currently ranked teams slated to play the Aggies between now and Nov. 20.

    The Tigers play in a weaker division, and their schedule isn't quite as demanding, but they still have dates with Nebraska and Oklahoma to worry about in the next few weeks. I'm inclined to think they haven't really been tested yet.

    That should change this weekend. And I'm going to give a slight edge — in another upset — to Texas A&M.

  • Mississippi State at #22 Florida, 6 p.m. on ESPNU: Florida has every reason to be cocky heading into this game.

    The Gators are 14–5 in this irregular series since 1980. And they haven't lost to Mississippi State at home since 1965.

    I'll take Florida.

  • #23 Air Force at San Diego State, 7 p.m. on CBSCSN: This series has ebbed and flowed over the years.

    Lately, the advantage has been with Air Force, winner of four of the last five. But prior to that, San Diego State won three in a row.

    Before that, Air Force won four straight.

    I guess that would suggest that it's San Diego State's turn, that the pendulum is now swinging in the Aztecs' direction. And maybe it is. San Diego State played decently in its only game against a currently ranked team (Missouri) and lost by a field goal. But I suppose I am more impressed by Air Force's three–point loss at Oklahoma a few weeks ago.

    Give me Air Force.

  • #24 Oregon State at Washington, 9:15 p.m. on ESPN: Oregon State has won six straight against Washington.

    It's been a nice change for Beavers fans, who were flogged by the Huskies on a regular basis in the 1980s and 1990s.

    Will either team flog the other this week? I don't know. Both offenses are mediocre — Washington's is 52nd in the nation, Oregon State's is 82nd. But the defenses are worse — Washington is 104th, Oregon State is 113th.

    So why is Oregon State in the Top 25? The Beavers lost to TCU and Boise State earlier this season, but they have beaten both of the Arizona schools in the last couple of weeks.

    Washington State, meanwhile, has only a one–point win against Montana State so far this year.

    The Cougars will have to wait at least another week for win #2. I pick Oregon State.
Last week: 16–3

Season: 105–15

Thursday, October 7, 2010

A Unique Week



You may not realize this. It may have snuck in under your personal radar. But this is truly a remarkable week in college football.

For the first time in nearly half a century — since November 1960 — the Associated Press' college football poll does not include Texas, Notre Dame, USC or Penn State.

Those schools were always fixtures in the rankings when I was growing up. And, even though Notre Dame has never been ranked this year, the other three have been — which fed the illusion that perhaps not so much about college football had actually changed.

In some ways, I guess, things aren't so radically different. Alabama is ranked #1 — which was a frequent occurrence when I was growing up. And teams like Ohio State, Nebraska and Oklahoma are in the Top 10.

But there have been changes. Just look at today's rankings — where teams like Boise State, TCU, Utah, Nevada and Air Force occupy spots in the Top 25 (which was the Top 20 when I was growing up). When I was a child, those schools were lucky if they won more games than they lost. Today, some are mentioned as contenders for a national title.

If anything, though, expectations at the big traditional powers are the same as they have always been — and the price to be paid if one fails to meet those expectations can be steep indeed.

I suppose, as Berry Tramel writes in The Oklahoman, Oklahoma coach Bob Stoops solved his "Texas Problem" with OU's 28–20 victory over the now–unranked Longhorns.

"Stoops had lost four of five to the Longhorns," Tramel says, "but he won't join the club of Snorter Luster, Bud Wilkinson and Gary Gibbs, OU coaches who went 1–5 in a six–year span of this series and never coached the Sooners again."

They do take football seriously in Oklahoma, even in what Okies consider "off years" — and it is definitely hard to think of a season in which the Sooners are 5–0, ranked sixth in the nation and appear likely to cruise to an unblemished regular–season record as an "off year."

It's probably a good thing, though, for both Stoops and his players, that the schedule gives them a break this week. They'll be back in action a week from Saturday, when Iowa State visits Norman. That gives them time to release a little of the pressure.

Anyway, now that the annual OU–vs.–UT debate has been settled, the focus seems to be shifting to the question of who is #2 to Alabama in the nation? Pete Thamel tries to shed some light on that particular discussion in the New York Times.

In addition to #6 Oklahoma, #15 Iowa also is idle this week. All times are Central.

Today
  • #7 Nebraska at Kansas State, 6:30 p.m. on ESPN: In all but six of their last 50 meetings, Nebraska has beaten Kansas State. I guess it goes without saying that Nebraska has been dominating the series in the last five decades.

    It's an odd kind of rivalry, as the Omaha World–Herald says. And, barring some unexpected developments in the future, it may be the last game in the series, with Nebraska bolting for the Big Ten next year.

    There was a time, in the late 1990s and early 2000s, when Kansas State had the upper hand. In fact, half of KSU's wins over the Cornhuskers in the last half century came between 2002 and 2004. But those were at the end of what passed for Kansas State's golden era in football.

    That era is over — but the Cornhuskers, after wandering in the football wilderness for awhile, seem to be enjoying a revival. And I expect Nebraska to get its sixth straight win against Kansas State.

    Speculation — now that Texas has dropped two games in a row and seems likely to lose to Nebraska next week — is that Oklahoma and Nebraska may meet in the Big 12 title game in December. Considering the history of that series, OU–NU would make that a memorable event indeed — especially if a national championship date with Alabama (or Ohio State) was riding on the outcome.
Friday
  • #22 Oklahoma State at Louisiana–Lafayette, 8 p.m. on ESPN2: I don't remember the first time that someone pointed out to me that Louisiana–Lafayette's abbreviation was U–La–La. I just remember thinking it was one of the funniest things I had ever heard (up to that time, anyway).

    I guess I should point out that was a long, long time ago (in a galaxy far, far away ... but I digress).

    Well, these schools have played each other before — OSU won by 56–3 in 2003, by 24–7 in 1999, by 44–20 in 1998, by 31–7 in 1997, by 36–0 in 1987 and by 21–20 in 1986 — so the current crop of Cowboys shouldn't burst into giggles if someone tells them that (even though none of OSU's current players was on the roster the last time U–La–La came to Stillwater).

    Oklahoma State still has some improvements to make, but I think OSU should handle Louisiana–Lafayette with little difficulty.
Saturday
  • #1 Alabama at #19 South Carolina, 2:30 p.m. on CBS: In the last two weeks, Alabama turned back Arkansas on the road and manhandled Florida at home.

    Ray Glier of the New York Times says the Crimson Tide has met every challenge and still looks like a champ. But he admits that the schedule is the "[o]ne thing that may derail Alabama." And this week's opponent, #19 South Carolina, is 'Bama's third straight ranked foe.

    Matt Hayes of The Sporting News suggests this game has the makings of a classic ambush. It could be, he speculates, like when Texas encountered that "trap door" against Texas Tech.

    Actually, South Carolina may feel it always was a more likely winner than Arkansas or Florida. The Razorbacks are a much–improved team, but they ran out of gas against Alabama, and the Gators just aren't the same without Tim Tebow.

    Last year, South Carolina was one of nine SEC teams to lose to Alabama — but only Tennessee came closer to beating the Crimson Tide. And, in four previous encounters since 2000, each team won twice.

    So the Gamecocks may well be ready to give the Crimson Tide their best shot. That's becoming a way of life in Alabama. Safety Mark Barron said, "Every game is like that for us." For Alabama, it must be sort of like that scene in "Airplane!" where the other passengers are lining up to punch the hysterical passenger. Next week it's Ole Miss. The week after that, it's Tennessee. Then the Crimson Tide gets the week off before traveling to Baton Rouge to take on LSU.

    You get the idea.

    At least the Gamecocks have home field in their favor, you might say, but the home field hasn't necessarily been an advantage for either team. They both went 1–1 at home in the four games prior to last year's meeting.

    I'm tempted to pick South Carolina, because I feel 'Bama is overdue — and maybe a little overconfident. South Carolina might keep it close for awhile, might even lead for awhile, but I'll pick Alabama to wear 'em down and win this one.

    For those who are hoping for 'Bama's comeuppance, that will have to wait for another day.

  • Indiana at #2 Ohio State, 11 a.m. on ESPN: Ohio State has won 15 straight against Indiana.

    In 1990, the teams battled to a 27–27 tie. That is as close as Indiana has come to beating Ohio State in two decades.

    Before that, Indiana did manage to beat the Buckeyes twice in the late 1980s, but, even so, between 1971 and 1989, Ohio State was 17–2 against the Hoosiers.

    What's more, Ohio State almost always uses the occasion to run up a big margin of victory. Historically, a date with the Indiana football team has been the cure for whatever has been ailing the Buckeyes (although there have been some exceptions). And, as Ken Gordon reports in the Columbus Dispatch, there is considerable concern about the Buckeyes' Heisman hopeful, quarterback Terrelle Pryor, and his injured thigh.

    Hoosier buddy? Hoosier pal?

    A game with Indiana may be just the medicine Ohio State needs right now.

  • #3 Oregon at Washington State: Last week, I picked Stanford to defeat Oregon in their Pac–10 showdown. I admitted it was an upset special, but that was my pick, however it was labeled.

    Oregon impressed me, though, and, apparently, also impressed the voters in the Associated Press poll, leaping past Boise State in the rankings.

    I still think Stanford is a legitimate team (and the Cardinal will get the chance to prove it against USC on Saturday), but Oregon proved something to me in that victory.

    There will not, however, be much for the Ducks to prove this week. The opponent is 1–4 Washington State, which has been outscored by a 2–to–1 margin thus far.

    Oregon, meanwhile, has been outscoring its foes by a nearly 4–to–1 margin while compiling a 5–0 mark.

    The Ducks also have won more than two–thirds of their meetings with the Cougars since 1991. It's no stretch to say that I expect Oregon to win this game.

  • Toledo at #4 Boise State, 7 p.m. on ESPN3.com: Toledo did beat Purdue a couple of weeks ago, but, honestly, does anyone think this 3–2 team that lost to Wyoming at home last Saturday can possibly win at Boise State?

    I didn't think so.

    Boise State should cruise.

  • Wyoming at #5 TCU, 2:30 p.m. on CBSCSN: The history of this brief series favors TCU, with four wins in the last five years.

    As nearly as I can tell, they met only once before they became members of the same conference, but Wyoming beat TCU in Fort Worth in 1998 — so it can happen.

    Not that it is likely to.

    Wyoming snapped a three–game losing streak with its win over Toledo last weekend, but all three of the Cowboys' losses came to teams that were ranked at the time (Texas and Boise State) or were on their way to being ranked (Air Force). I think the Cowboys could keep it close, but I am certain TCU will win.

  • #8 Auburn at Kentucky, 6:30 p.m. on ESPN2: When Kentucky beat Auburn last season, it snapped a 15–game losing streak for the Wildcats.

    They hadn't won at Auburn since 1961.

    The last time Kentucky beat Auburn at home was 1966. I think it is safe to say that won't change.

    Give me Auburn.

  • Oregon State at #9 Arizona: Oregon State has won nine of the last 11 games against Arizona and hasn't lost at Arizona since 1997.

    But I'm inclined to think things will be different this year. Arizona is on the way up, ranked second in the nation in total defense — and doing pretty well in total offense (ranked in the top 40). Oregon State, on the other hand, is 99th in offense and 104th in defense.

    Of course, it's hard to draw any conclusions from just four games, but, in addition to the rankings advantage, Arizona also has won its only encounter with a ranked team (Iowa). Oregon State has faced two ranked opponents so far (Boise State and TCU) and lost to both.

    I'll take Arizona.

  • #10 Utah at Iowa State, 6 p.m. on FCS: As nearly as I can tell, these schools haven't faced each other since 1976.

    On that occasion — exactly 34 years ago (and on the same field) — Utah avenged its loss to Iowa State the previous year.

    Utah is a much better team today, and Iowa State is much worse. I pick Utah.


  • #11 Arkansas vs. Texas A&M at Arlington, Texas, 2:30 p.m. on ABC: Last year, in the teams' first meeting since they were Southwest Conference rivals, Arkansas won, 47–19.

    A&M won their last two SWC meetings (in 1990 and 1991), but the Razorbacks have won some memorable games with the Aggies over the years. They won far more with the Aggies than they lost when I was growing up so A&M was one of those teams that I always assumed Arkansas would beat — even on occasions when nothing much was expected from Arkansas and everything was expected from Texas A&M.

    Two such occasions stand out in my memory — Dec. 6, 1975, and Nov. 15, 1986.

    In 1975, the teams had agreed to move their game to the first weekend in December to accommodate national television. It would be nearly 20 years before conferences began playing championship games so that weekend was always rather bland. Most of the regular–season games were done, and the only games being played were oddities, like Army–Navy, which never had much of a bearing on anything when I was growing up.

    A&M was coming off a huge win over rival Texas and came into Little Rock ranked second in the nation. But the Razorbacks, in what turned out to be the last coaching hurrah for Frank Broyles, whipped the previously unbeaten Aggies, 31–6. As I remember, it was a typically cold, gray December day in central Arkansas, and I recall watching the game on TV, occasionally nibbling on my mother's freshly baked banana bread.

    The Razorbacks went on to represent the SWC in the Cotton Bowl.

    In 1986, the teams met again in Little Rock. I was working for the Arkansas Gazette sports department in those days, and football season meant a lot of long, unpaid hours on weekends. So, as a form of compensation, each sports staffer was allowed one Saturday off with pay. If a staffer's Saturday coincided with a Razorback game in Little Rock, he could get free tickets to the game through the department. They usually weren't great, around the 5– or 10–yard lines, but they were free.

    That year, I took my Saturday off in mid–November, and I got three tickets to the A&M game. I went with a couple of buddies of mine. National TV cameras were on hand. The Aggies were ranked seventh, the Hogs were 17th, and, this time, the Aggies went on to represent the SWC in Dallas.

    They weren't undefeated, though. The Razorbacks beat them that cold, gray November afternoon.

    Clearly, I associate "cold and gray" with great moments in Razorback history! It won't be cold or gray in Arlington on Saturday, but I still think Arkansas will win the game.

  • #12 LSU at #14 Florida, 6:30 p.m. on ESPN: Given the success these teams have enjoyed in the last decade, you would think that they would have met in the SEC championship game at some point.

    But, although both schools won national titles in the first decade of the 21st century, they haven't met with the SEC crown on the line.

    For fans who love offense, that probably isn't bad news. The Gators are currently ranked 84th in the nation in total offense and LSU is ranked 91st. Defense is where both teams excel — LSU is ranked sixth, Florida is ranked 19th. And, remember, Florida's defense has faced Alabama. LSU won't have that pleasure for another month.

    I think it will be a tough defensive game, with the final score in the vicinity of 13–10 or 14–13. Unless it goes into overtime. Then all bets are off.

    But I'll pick LSU — if for no other reason than the fact that the SEC West is dominating the East this year.

  • #23 Florida State at #13 Miami (Florida), 7 p.m. on ABC: These teams have met every year since 1969, and the series could hardly be much closer (Miami holds a 22–19 edge).

    Over the years, they've treated college football fans to some of the most entertaining games that have been played.

    And this contest looks like another drama–filled affair.

    The numbers say Florida State should have a substantial edge on offense. The Seminoles are ranked 30th in the nation while the Hurricanes are 70th. Both teams have played well on defense. A slight edge goes to Miami, which is ranked 12th in the nation, but Florida State's defense is 21st.

    Both teams suffered their only setback to Top 10 teams on the same day (Sept. 11). Miami lost to Ohio State, Florida State lost to Oklahoma. Both losses came on the road.

    I think it will be close. I think it may be low scoring. And I'll give the edge — however slight — to the home team, Miami.

  • USC at #16 Stanford, 7 p.m. on ABC: Since 1991, this has been a reasonably competitive series, with Stanford winning eight of 19 games, including some improbable upsets at USC.

    But Stanford has lost the last four times it has hosted USC. The last time Stanford beat USC at home was in 2000.

    USC just dropped out of the Top 25, following its loss to unranked Washington, so this will be an interesting challenge for Stanford.

    In true Pac–10 fashion, this may be a high–scoring affair. Both teams are in the top 20 in total offense (USC 13th, Stanford 16th) so it may come down to which team allows fewer points to be scored — and that brings us to what seems to be at the heart of USC's apparent implosion. Stanford is 44th in the nation in total defense. USC is 99th.

    I think Stanford will win a slugfest.

  • #17 Michigan State at #18 Michigan, 2:30 p.m. on ABC: In the battle for Michigan (and, frankly, with the economy the way it is, who wants it?), the Spartans have won the last two meetings. But, prior to 2008, the Wolverines won six in a row — and the Spartans' triumph in Ann Arbor two years ago was their first win in the Big House since 1990.

    Many college football fans are wondering if Michigan — a perennial national power when I was growing up but somewhat meek in recent years — really is "back." And it's a legitimate issue to ponder, given that the Wolverines have gone 5–7 and 3–9 in the last two years.

    In fact, when you stack the last couple of seasons up against just about any other two–year stretch in the team's history in the last half–century, it is understandable that Michigan fans should be anxious.

    When evaluating the reasons why Michigan might be back, it's worth pointing out that the Wolverines have the top Heisman candidate in QB Denard Robinson, at least according to ESPN.

    But that might not mean much to Michigan fans. They've had Heisman winners before.

    Dan Wetzel of rivals.com says all the pressure is on Michigan's coach.

    I'm not convinced, though. Michigan State's coach, who is recuperating from a recent heart attack, will be coaching from the press box. Guess the temptation to be on hand in case the Spartans beat the Wolverines for the third straight year for the first time since the mid–to–late 1960s was too great.

    Or maybe the pressure from boosters and administrators was too great?

    Anyway, the question is, will the Spartans make it three in a row? And I'm going to predict that the answer will be yes. Michigan State will win the game.

  • Minnesota at #20 Wisconsin, 11 a.m. on Big Ten Network: Wisconsin has beaten Minnesota six straight times.

    But the Badgers haven't been as dominant as that might suggest. Most of the time, they have had to win close games.

    I know Wisconsin lost a real heartbreaker to Michigan State last week, but Minnesota has lost four in a row — a skid that began when South Dakota beat the Gophers at home.

    And, yes, all four of Minnesota's losses have been close (with the possible exception of the Gophers' 11–point loss to USC), but mounting losses can take their toll.

    I just can't see Minnesota winning this game, although it might be close. Give me Wisconsin.

  • San Jose State at #21 Nevada, 9:30 p.m. on ESPNU: I really don't think Nevada will be seriously challenged until next month, when it faces Fresno State and Boise State.

    I certainly don't think that 1–4 San Jose State, loser of seven of its last eight against this foe, will be much of an obstacle for unbeaten Nevada.

  • Colorado at #24 Missouri, 6 p.m. on FSN: There was a time when Colorado had a dominant football team.

    And, in its glory days, Colorado routinely beat Missouri, occasionally by ridiculous margins.

    But those days are gone. I'll take Missouri.

  • Colorado State at #25 Air Force, 11 a.m. on The Mtn.: Let's see. Air Force has won its last four games against Colorado State.

    Air Force also has one of the nation's best rushing attacks. The Falcons are in the Top 25. And they are at home.

    The choice seems clear — Air Force.
Last week: 11–4

Season: 89–12

Saturday, October 2, 2010

About an Hour South of the Red River ...

... you'll find tens of thousands of people in Dallas today dressed in Oklahoma red and Texas orange making their way to the big rivalry football game.

This game would have had a lot more appeal if Texas hadn't dropped the ball against UCLA last week. But it does look like the weather will be pleasant for those folks sitting in the stands — and those young men slugging it out on the field.

Still, five games, including OU–Texas, match teams in the Top 25 today so college football fans have a lot to enjoy. Meanwhile, five teams in the Top 25 are idle this week — #6 Nebraska, #13 Utah, #14 Arizona, #15 Arkansas and #19 South Carolina.

All times are Central.

Berry Tramel of The Oklahoman thinks defense will be the key to today's OU–Texas game. But that just seems to be the norm, as far as I am concerned. When I was growing up, the defenses always seemed to be in charge, even in those years when one school had a soon–to–be–named Heisman Trophy winner on its roster.

Sure, there have been some years when the Sooners and the Longhorns lit up the scoreboard, but more often, it seems, there have been scores like last year's 16–13 Texas victory. In fact, while there have been some lopsided scores in the last decade, half the time since 2000 the winning team has had 28 points or less — and many of those times, the winning team didn't even score 20 points.

So anticipating a defensive struggle is not an outlandish thing to do — certainly not in this series.

By the way, today's forecast for Dallas calls for sunny and a light breeze with a high of 85° — still a little warm but not unpleasant, compared to recent temperatures in this area.

Football fans in this part of the country tend to lose sight of the fact that football rules in other parts of the country as well — and the pressure to succeed is great. Ron Musselman writes in the Pittsburgh Post–Gazette that the pressure level goes up for Penn State when its Big Ten conference schedule begins.

That schedule begins today for the 22nd–ranked Nittany Lions, when they visit #17 Iowa.

Today
  • #7 Florida at #1 Alabama, 7 p.m. on CBS: Things don't get easier for defending national champion Alabama.

    Of course, life is never easy if you're in the SEC. Last week, Alabama survived an improved Arkansas squad, 24–20, on the road. And, this week, the Crimson Tide must host Florida (the team they whipped, 32–13, in last year's SEC championship game), a week after the Gators' freshman quarterback accounted for all six TDs in Florida's win over Kentucky.

    In 2008, Florida prevailed over 'Bama, 31–20, to claim the SEC crown.

    As members of different divisions, the teams face each other occasionally during the regular season. And, today, they resume regular–season play for the first time since 2006.

    The last time they played in Alabama was in 2005, and the Crimson Tide won, 31–3. The following year, when they met in Florida, the Gators won, 28–13.

    You might conclude, based on those scores, that home field is the difference. But home field is not the key to success in this series. Alabama won when it traveled to Florida on this date in 1999, 40–39, then beat Florida a second time in the SEC title game (which has been played in Atlanta for the last 16 years). And the year before, when Florida traveled to Alabama, the Gators won, 16–10.

    That was actually Florida's third straight win over Alabama. The Gators won two straight SEC title games against the Crimson Tide in 1993 and 1994 after losing the inaugural SEC title game in 1992.

    Anyway, with a few exceptions, the last 20 years have belonged to Florida in its series with Alabama. And Mike Bianchi of the Orlando Sentinel unabashedly asserts that Florida will win today. "Alabama is overconfident," he concluded after wearing a Florida jersey into a Tuscaloosa eatery that reportedly was a favorite of Bear Bryant's.

    But I'm inclined to think the Gators will struggle without Tim Tebow against the Tide today. Alabama may be a bit banged up after a physical confrontation with Arkansas last week, but I think the Tide will win.

  • #2 Ohio State at Illinois, 11 a.m. on the Big Ten Network: If there is a conclusion to be reached about the Ohio State–Illinois series from the head–to–head meetings in the past, it is this: Ohio State usually wins ... unless Illinois is enjoying a successful season.

    And, at the moment, one could conclude, based on its record so far (2–1), that Illinois is having a good season. But that kinda breaks down when you examine it more closely. Illinois' two wins have come against Northern Illinois and Southern Illinois. The loss came against a Big 12 team, Missouri — and, although Illinois had last week off, the Illini are about to embark on a three–week stretch in which they must face conference foes that are in the Top 25 — Ohio State, Penn State and Michigan State,

    The second–ranked team in the nation should be quite a test for the Illini. Too much of test, I think. I'll take Ohio State.

  • #3 Boise State at New Mexico State: Boise State has beaten New Mexico State 11 straight times since 1996.

    Does anyone think that streak is in jeopardy? I didn't think so.

    Neither do I. Boise State should win this one easily.

  • #9 Stanford at #4 Oregon, 7 p.m. on ABC: Until Stanford won a 51–42 shootout at home last year, Oregon had beaten Stanford seven straight times.

    For awhile last Saturday, it looked like Oregon might not be able to put away unranked Arizona State — and and a loss would have prevented this week's game from being arguably the biggest in the series' history. But Oregon rallied and leaped past TCU in the rankings; meanwhile Stanford crushed hapless Notre Dame to set up a Top 10 matchup today.

    But, in spite of the higher ranking, the home field advantage and the winning streak that was alive and well until last season, Oregon should be afraid, very afraid. Mike Lopresti of USA Today thinks Stanford has been the most impressive team in the first month of the season.

    Lopresti says Stanford is "enormously fun to watch" — but I don't think the Cardinal would be enormously fun to face. Stanford is 26 of 26 in the red zone.

    And I think Stanford will win. I'll grant you, it's an upset special. But I don't think last year's outcome was a fluke.

  • #5 TCU at Colorado State, 1 p.m. on The Mtn: All around Dallas last week, I saw yard signs imploring the locals to "Fill the Ford" for the SMU–TCU rivalry game on Friday night.

    I watched part of the game and thought TCU looked uninspired while SMU did look inspired — which is what I would have expected. A win over a Top 10 TCU program would have been an impressive achievement for the SMU program. But the Mustangs ran out of gas.

    And, no, it did not look as if they "filled the Ford." But, as the Dallas Morning News wrote Saturday, SMU is on the right track, and the time will come when a ticket to an SMU game in Gerald Ford Stadium will be the hottest ticket in town.

    But the Mustangs aren't there yet.

    The Horned Frogs are, though. They just need a couple of breaks to get into the national title game. A signature win wouldn't hurt, but they aren't going to get one by beating Colorado State (3–9 last year and 1–3 so far in 2010). TCU lost to Colorado State in 1998, but the Frogs have won their six meetings since. I expect TCU to extend that streak to seven.

  • #8 Oklahoma vs. #21 Texas at Dallas, 2:30 p.m. on ABC: They've taken to calling this the "Red River Rivalry." For a long time, I believe, it was called the "Red River Shootout," but they stopped doing that, perhaps to discourage gun violence.

    I've lived in both states, and I don't think the phrasing of the label for a college rivalry is going to influence gun use in either place.

    I grew up in Arkansas, and we always just called it the OU–Texas game. In those days, the teams didn't play in the same conference, but both were almost always in the Top 10 when they met every October, so the game had national championship implications.

    But you wanna know something? History really means nothing in this series.

    Now, I wouldn't ignore history, especially recent history. Texas trails few of its football series with other schools, and the historical numbers clearly favor the Longhorns against the Sooners. They have 59 wins, Oklahoma has 40, and there have been five ties.

    The Longhorns also have dominated the recent series, winning four of the last five.

    So you might think the numbers favor Texas.

    But all that says is that recent momentum has been with the 'Horns. Over and over and over again in this series, one school has been down for a few years, only to rise up and turn back its nemesis and start a new streak that favors the other team.

    Rarely in the history of the series has one school dominated the other for longer than five years — and, with the exception of a 28–21 loss to the Sooners in 2007, UT has been on top for the last five years.

    That is the one historical trend that makes sense to me. I think the pendulum is swinging in the other direction now, and I think the Longhorns have a lot of problems that only begin with the fact that they're having to break in a freshman quarterback.

    Don't get me wrong. Oklahoma hasn't exactly covered itself with glory. I know that OU struggled to beat Cincinnati last Saturday, but Texas was downright awful in its loss to UCLA.

    Texas has a good defense — when the UT offense isn't asking it to perform miracles — but so does OU. And the Sooners have an offensive line, which Texas really doesn't. So, all things considered, I have to pick Oklahoma.

  • Louisiana–Monroe at #10 Auburn, 11 a.m. on ESPNU: This will be the eighth time the teams have faced each other since 1994.

    Auburn has won the previous seven meetings. Sometimes Louisiana–Monroe hasn't even scored.

    I expect no less today. Auburn should win handily.

  • #11 Wisconsin at #24 Michigan State, 2:30 p.m. on ABC: Here's an interesting trend.

    These teams don't face each other every year, but the last five times they have met, the home team has emerged with the victory.

    However, the last time the home team didn't win was in 2002 — when Michigan State was the host.

    Shannon Shelton of the Detroit Free–Press writes that this game is the first big test that Michigan State has faced this year. In a sense, that is true of both teams. Neither has faced a high–caliber foe so far.

    But it seems to me that Michigan State may have more to prove. Wisconsin's football reputation (eight straight bowl appearances and 13 bowls in the last 14 years) seems to be well established. Michigan State has been to bowls for three straight years now, but the Spartans have been more sporadic.

    I think this may be like that '02 game. The score may be closer (the Badgers won that game by 18 points), but I'll go with Wisconsin.

  • Tennessee at #12 LSU, 2:30 p.m. on CBS: The last time these schools faced each other was for the SEC championship in 2007. LSU won, 21–14, and went on to beat Ohio State for the national title.

    Prior to that, they played 10 times in 30 years, with Tennessee winning most of the time, 6–3–1.

    But times have changed, and LSU enters this game with a more solid program — as well as the home field advantage.

    I think LSU will win today.

  • #16 Miami (Florida) at Clemson, 11 a.m. on ESPN2: The schools haven't been in the same conference very long, and they compete in different divisions so they don't play every year.

    In face, they have only played three times, and the visiting team has won every time.

    Works for me. I'll take Miami.

  • #22 Penn State at #17 Iowa, 7 p.m. on ESPN: Penn State has beaten Iowa only five times in 13 meetings since the Nittany Lions joined the Big Ten, and three of those wins came right out of the gate.

    So, Iowa has dominated the series, 8–2, since then. But one of those wins came at Iowa (in 1999), and the bad news for Penn State was that Iowa won only one game that year.

    Iowa has won the last three encounters at home, and I expect that trend to continue.

  • Washington at #18 USC, 7 p.m. on ABC: Washington snapped a seven–year losing streak to USC last season with a 16–13 triumph.

    But winning in Trojan Country is something the Huskies haven't done in their last three visits, and I don't think that will change today. I'll take USC.

  • #20 Michigan at Indiana, 2:30 p.m. on ESPNU: These two teams don't face each other every year, but, in good seasons or bad, Michigan has beaten Indiana the last 16 times they have met.

    Indiana's last win over Michigan came in 1987, when the Hoosiers won at home, 14–10. The Wolverines won 15 in a row against Indiana prior to that.

    Anyway, as I have written before, I'm not sure if Michigan is back as a football power. And I don't really think we will find out when the Wolverines take the field against the Hoosiers today. Michigan should improve to 5–0, and we will start finding out whether Michigan is really back when the Wolverines face Michigan State next week.

  • Virginia Tech at #23 North Carolina State, 2:30 p.m. on ABC: After beating Georgia Tech, North Carolina State finds itself in the Top 25 — and, I must concede, the Wolfpack deserves to be there.

    It has to make you wonder what might have been if Virginia Tech hadn't lost to James Madison.

    They've only been in the same conference for a brief time, and they play in separate divisions so they don't face each other every year. Since 1989, they have played seven times, and North Carolina State has won only once — 7–0 at home in 1991.

    If not for the JMU loss, I might be tempted to pick Tech in this one. But I'm just not sold on the Hokies so I'll take North Carolina State.

  • #25 Nevada at UNLV, 9 p.m. on The Mtn.: Nevada has gone 12–6 against UNLV since 1992.

    In all those years, neither team has won more than five in a row against the other. And Nevada has beaten UNLV the last five times they have faced each other. But I think Nevada will make it six in a row.

    After all, the Wolf Pack is ranked for the first time since Truman was president. And they're on TV.

Last week: 19–2

Season: 78–8

Friday, October 1, 2010

The Thrilla in Manila



For me, it is really incredible to think that it has been 35 years since the "Thrilla in Manila," the third and final fight between Joe Frazier and Muhammad Ali.

Few rivalries between individual athletes could match Ali and Frazier in the 1970s. The nation truly was transfixed every time they fought. I always felt that was because they represented — symbolically, at least — each side of the cultural divide that existed in those days. Ali, with his rebellious nature and his refusal to fight in the increasingly unpopular Vietnam War, seemed to represent the doves, whereas the obedient, establishmentarian Frazier represented the hawks in American society.

I was a great admirer of Ali as a boy, and one of the things I appreciated about him was that, after he won the title from George Foreman, he brought boxing back to the people. Prior to the second Ali championship era, most fights were shown only on closed–circuit TV. But after Ali defeated Foreman, most of his title defenses were on commercial TV.

Of course, at that point in his career, few of Ali's foes were truly on his level. But that didn't matter. I remember eagerly looking forward to those fights.

But the "Thrilla in Manila" was an exception, in more ways than one. Not only did it match Ali with a worthy adversary, but the fight was televised by the fledgling HBO network — which was then, as it is now, a subscription service — and its broadcast via satellite from the Philippines can be reasonably said to have been a pioneering event in the development of modern satellite TV transmission.

And, too, I always felt that, if it wasn't the initial inspiration, the "Thrilla" must have had some influence on the story that was told in the original "Rocky." At the very least, it was a damn good example of art imitating life — or perhaps anticipating is a better word.

In Manila, the defending champion Ali and his entourage did not take the fight seriously, believing they were doing Frazier a favor by giving him one more moment in the spotlight. But Frazier took the fight very seriously and went 14 rounds with Ali before losing by technical knockout.

Ali — whose blase approach to the fight encouraged many distractions that were unrelated to what he needed to do in the ring — was suitably impressed with Frazier. Before the fight, he believed Frazier was just a shell of his formerly dominant self after his humiliating loss to Foreman two years earlier.

But after the fight, Ali told anyone who would listen that Frazier "is the greatest fighter of all times ... next to me."

That was pretty high praise coming from a man who fought Sonny Liston (twice), George Foreman and Ken Norton, among others.